Is it only American women who suffer from PMS?

Question

My fiance, who was raised by his Thai mother and his Puerto Rican step-mother, believes that PMS is the American woman's excuse to be b*tchy. Although he believes that we American women suffer the symptoms of PMS he believes it's mental due to "brainwashing" by American culture. He's convinced that there are no other nationality that experiences PMS.

I've lived all over the world; unfortunately this topic never came up. Do other cultures experience PMS? Is it exactly like the "American version"? How do other cultures deal with PMS?

Answer 1

The physical symptoms of PMS are universal to all women. We all get the cramps, fatigue, and all of those other things which aren't fun. Of course it varies with each female. But what also varies is our attitudes about it. I wouldn't say Americans are the only ones, but as a society we do tend to have a spoiled attitude about it (as in we don't consider that others suffer too). Perhaps women in other nations just don't share that attitude.

Answer 2

PMS is real but I usually take a couple of Advil and I'm fine. I don't get bitchy or anything like that. I think many women do use the PMS for their attitudes and yes i do think the brainwashing is instilled in the american culture. i'm not sure if no other nationalities experience this. i'm sure they do but they probably don't make it as big of a deal as the americans do. i don't think PMS is more of a cultural thing, so i dont agree with you in that classification but i do beleive it's based on each woman and how they deal with it. by the way, i live in NY and i do see it as a woman's excuse.

Answer 3

Whoever gets the activity might get the activity via fact they have been judged via the voters to be the main in large condition for the situation. If a woman candidate had a concern with temper swings etc led to by PMS, it would rather no longer circulate no longer noted for the period of her campaign etc. various men have had temper swings in place of work. Any woman who can gain a "guy's worldwide" of politics already knows the thank you to handle thoughts and to reign them in as mandatory. The question must be a valid one, yet relatively does not notice in this sort of outrage. as an occasion to teach my factor, one ought to argue that a woman should not be a physician or an emergency room physician via fact if she had PMS sometime, it ought to value somebody their life. What if a woman became right into a chemist for a substantial pharmaceutical business agency that became into doing drug trials on volunteers? think the lady had a PMS 2d and used in straightforward terms a sprint too a lot of a definite chemical. it ought to have disastrous outcomes. I propose, this good judgment relatively isn't logical. PMS isn't the priority right here. many women have it and various women do no longer. I for one have not at all had it. At subject right this is how a woman OR a guy, handles stress and changing circumstances, inclusive of how they're feeling on a particular day, and different components which could influence their point of stress. If a individual is able to deal with stress in a peaceful and professional way, then that must be a trademark that they might a minimum of be straightforward to no longer push the pink button in the event that they have been President.

Answer 4

Well in many other cultures, the women aren't allowed to say much. They often suffer in silence, and thats probably why you don't see so much. To say that PMS is a American womans problem exclusively, is a stupid comment. Another example of how IGNORANCE is a dangerous disease! Menstrual problems are very very real in many women.

Answer 5

people are people. People with certain problems will feel a certain way - wether it is recongized or not. Ohter countries may not understand it -women may be afraid to compalin-
there was a time when American Drs thought it was all in your head. Give the rest of the world time to catch up.

Answer 6

Besides, in America, if it has a name, it can have a diagnosis, they can make prescriptions for it, and do commercials to convince you that you can't function without the drug.

Yes, all women globally have PMS, but our culture is more verbal and "scientific" (read: commercial) about it.

Answer 7

American women are bitchy because they think they are entitled to certain things (like all americans)

truth is they are lucky to even have a period, in some countries you cant without the governments permission...freedom isnt free

Answer 8

I'm not pre b!tchy only b!tchy one or two days during. So hmm I don't know. Kinda depends doesn't it? Probably different from woman to woman.

Answer 9

it's a biological constant in all women, though things like diet and lifestyle might affect it, so it could be absent in some places and more significant in others.

Answer 10

yea, i think americans sometime complains too much.