Toshiba Gigabeat S 30gb or a Creative Zen Vision:M 30gb player?

Question

I can't decide between getting a Toshiba Gigabeat S 30gb or a Creative Zen Vision:M 30gb player. I will use it primarily for music, but like that the Gigabeat has the USB port and can easily connect to a TV to play video on a TV.
As far as audio, I was told that the Gigabeat won't allow playlists, but I have read about a quicklist option. Can playlists be synced/uploaded to the Gigabeat? How does the quicklist work?

I am unsure about the ease of using the Zen for connecting to speakers or a TV. CNET loves the Toshiba, and PCMag loves the Zen. Any suggestions from current users or what the pros and cons of both players are welcome.

Answer 1

yah i had the same prob im gonna get the vision m well becuae it doesnt encrypt your music files after transferin em to ue mp3player meaning u can share music with others like the toshiba. the only good thing about the toshiba is the nice big screen and the nice interface if you want fo music would definitly go witht the visionm well cuz creative is known for there very nice auio quality also the vision m canconnect to a tv it comes with the sync adapter all you need to do is buy the av cable from creative wel the pros of the creative zen vision m are the very nice screen quality, kickass sound quaklity, themes are changeable compatibe with most movie types, fm radio built in microphone, compatibe with most music services
cons: uhh uhhoh yah the lack one scratches almot as eaily as the ipod and u uh uhyah thas al i can think of
toshiba pros: nice audio nice pics umm big screen nice interface
cons: protects aduio files no sharing, you can here the hard drive spinningis what i heard, not sure if firware upgrades arent allowed, i think theres no fm radio not sure and no microphone

Answer 2

I actual have the Toshiba Gigabeat and in spite of the indisputable fact that it is not as person pleasant because the Ipod, it actual is a prize to have. when I realized a thanks to upload, receive, delete and format, i became in listener heaven. i'd purchase back if I damage or lose it. it truly is astounding for reading an effective e book also. large for workout time. Your community library has many books of all style to hearken to. My determination: Toshiba...