Should step dad be allowed to smack me?

Question

I am a 12 year old boy and my mum recently married her boy friend. He has 2 sons aged 9 and 12 and when they misbehave he takes their trousers down puts them over his knee and smacks their bottoms with his hand or a slipper. Mum says now that he is my dad he can punish me in the same way. I have never been smacked with a slipper before and I am really scared.

Answer 1

Ask your mom why would she allow him to do that to you ,when she knows that you never been punished like that.If your dad is around see if you can go live with him.but there are rules that have to be followed no matter where you live and if you break a rule you need to be punished but in a different way.

Answer 2

your step dad shouldn't be allowed to smack you with a slipper or anything else. he is not your biological parent so he doesn't have the right too! your "mum" shouldn't inforce it either. by slipper do you mean thing you put on your foot? if it makes you feel better my parents didn't do it hard but they gave me a pat on the but with a wooden spoon. it didn't hurt that much and it was only after she gave us a worning and we were VERY naughty. i am 12 too. and haven't gotten spanked since i was um 6 or so. now my parents put me in a time out. (which i haven't recieved since i was nine) mabey you should convince you mom to put you in a time out instead, also just be a very good kid and do every thing you are told and you wont get spanked! hope this helps!

Answer 3

i'm a mom of three that remarried even as my children were 2, 5 and seven. My children are extremely properly behaved and continually were. With that suggested, i'm a extremely laid decrease back figure. My husband (has no bio children of his personal) became raised by employing very strict mum and dad and got here into the marriage wondering that if he suggested bounce the children might want to ask how intense!...ok possibly no longer that severe, yet you get the picture. He became getting pissed off with my comfortable sort and that i became getting fustrated including his strict beliefs. extremely of speaking it out promptly we allow it fester till we had a wide strive against. fortunately we were both able to calm down and talk issues out. We chanced on a center floor that we both agreed on and it has worked fairly properly. talk at the same time with your spouse. tell her the flaws that she does properly as a figure. tell her she is an mind-blowing mom. tell her the way you've been raised, the belongings you loved about the way you've been raised and the belongings you probably did not like. Ask her the way you both can artwork on getting your daughter (she is more suitable than the doorstep) to give up many of the habit that bothers you. grant your advice, hearken to hers. strong success! that is a complicated one. i do not ignore that I took it in my opinion even as my hubby informed me he idea i became too comfortable in some parenting aspects. i'm efficient it harm him when I informed him his perspectives were too strict. in case you're both prepared to be open and hear what the different individual is fairly keeping, you'll detect a answer that works for you both!!!

Answer 4

son Ive got a ten year old 8 a 5 and i smack ,but only with trousers up!!! listen 2 ashti she makes sense he ain't ya old man .
but you should listen 2 him
now comes the hard part you are going 2 be a man 1 day son so start now!
talk 2 him tell him that you want 2 talk about discipline, and how you think you should be disciplined .
come 2 an agreement on your rules and what happens 2 u if ya break em
bare butt smacking with shoe ain't on lad!!
don't be a smart **** just talk 2 him :) good luck
remember ya a man in waiting act like 1
(report all abuse)

Answer 5

If you've done something stupid, and you deserve punishment, then sure, why not? It's not as if he does it when you or your step-brothers don't misbehave, right?

If you're really scared or worried or whatever, I suggest you talk to him about it. I mean, he's hardly going to beat the crap out of you for starting a conversation about it..

He might be open to suggestions of alternative punishments. How does your mom punish you when you've done something bad?

I'll admit, his biological sons might feel that you're being a wuss and that they're being treated unfairly if you're given a different treatment come punishing time, but it's true. (No, not the wuss-part, the being treated differently one).

Talk to him. But hey, if you don't want to get hit? Don't misbehave ;)

Answer 6

Personally, no. No one has the right to hit a child. There are far more constructive and less abusive ways to discipline a child and hitting should never be an option. It's just the lazy way out of correcting a child. I was spanked as a kid, and now that I have my own baby I am exploring other ways to discipline and they are far more effective in my opinion. Good luck, hope you don't get hit.

Answer 7

It's a thin line wheather he should or not. You are his kid now, but he is not your biological father. He still has no right to tough you. Your mum can but he can't. Spanking, yeah it's a way of punishing, so what.

If it really bothers you, talk to him about it. Spankings don't really hurt though. Nothing to be scared about. Besides, just be good...

Answer 8

I think your Mom is right. It would be different if he was singling u out and you were the only one getting punished, but you are one of the kids and you are all being treated the same. Just be glad you have parents that care and want to see you raised right.

Answer 9

I dont agree with your mom He is not your biolodigical father and has no buisness touching you if he wants to punish like take something away or time out thats fine but hands on no she should do that or your biolodgical father!!!

Answer 10

My parents spanked me when i was out of line and i grew up fine. Just be on your best behavior and you don't have to worry about anything. Every child needs disaplin that is how they learn to have respect. I am on your moms side on this one. Go mom