Just like Palestine land was given to Israel, why not return USA back to the native Indians?

Question

I keep on hearing this absolutely stupid reasoning:
- Palestine land was given the the Jews after WW II because it used to belong to Israel 2000 years ago. Isn't that rationale absolutely stupid? If not, give USA back to the native Indians!

- Another absolutely stupid reasoning: Jews are people of God!
Says who? Jews? Bible? Those texts were written by Jews. It is called as Self-proclaimed-Divinity! Real BS!

Aren't non-Jews like us people of God? I will write it in a text if you want to.

Answer 1

Well mainly because we killed most of them and made sure they wouldn't be around to ask for it back.

There's a lesson there. If you are going to take a man's home, you'd better make sure he won't come back to reclaim it.

Answer 2

No we shouldn't provide the land back yet we favor to stay mutually for the mutual earnings of both. a huge phase of this society has community American blood. To be categorized as community American calls for a million/32 blood which maximum have fantastically interior the south. no doubt that community people were abused, mistreated, swindled and extra removed from their way of existence even if i believe that wrongs would nicely be made accurate and that i imagine that maximum will be keen to compromise on both facet. for people like me it will be a win win situation as i'm both and that i visit narrate to both facet of the area..the version between this example interior the U. S. and the middle east is that prophecy is that the Israelites could have warfare with those people through out time as a thorn of their facet. there'll be wars and rumors of wars. Israel will live to inform the tale. .

Answer 3

I take it you don't like Jews, you might have a point about land being taken from the Palestine's but we are way pass that now, so now what do we do, ( kill each other ) nobody going to win that game. So stop firing everyone up and make Peace

Answer 4

I wish I had the ability to every once in a while just be able to *****-slap someone just because they're stupid and are breathing air that should go to someone who deserves it. Have you never seen films or photos of the holocaust? Go through the Holocaust museum in D.C. or Israel. Visit the death camps in Poland, Germany and other places in Europe, then see if you want to make such a dum-assed statement. And by the way the government has given back a lot of land to native Americans. They're called "reservations" Stupid!

Answer 5

If we give it back to the Indians who do they give it back to??? The Indians where not "Nobel Savages" as Hollywood and indoctrination.. I mean education.....would like you to believe.
how do the individual tribes decide who ends up were.
I know that we could set them up with the land that they might have had when we showed up but who is going to decide where it goes from there, I mean they fought and battled for the best land the best hunting territory constantly, so are they then supposed to (once they receive the land that was taken from them) figure out who really had the land before them?? Unless you think they (the individual tribes) sprouted out of the ground right where they were when we showed up they had to have moved around and jockey'd about to find the best possible place for their tribe and invitedly had to move others out.
Not to mention that there have been found fossil remains of Caucasian people from 10 thousand + years ago. "i.e. "Kenna-wick Man" who was found with arrowheads of primitive people on this continent, as well as others. so who's to say who exterminated who first??? who took what land from who???
I know allot of terrible things have been done by our government but look at it this way. when the tables were turned did they give any kind of treaty to the tribes they conquered?? Did they treat their prisoners well???. They killed on a huge scale that when put into perspective killed many many more people per combatant and civilization than we ever did.
I know this is politically incorrect and you probably don't even want to think about things this way but if you think for YOURSELF and study books and theories of people whom think outside the world you've been educated in you could see the truth.

Answer 6

We've been brainwashed by zionists to feel pity for Jewish people.

I'm not racist...so don't throw that in my face. It's no different than saying I'm not for the Cuban government either, but you won't get called anti cuban for saying that! They've managed to put themselves in a position where they can throw anti semite at you if you look at them the wrong way. Here's a quote from the founder of zionism.



Theodor Herzl, founder of Zionism in 1897 “It is essential that the sufferings of Jews. . . become worse. . . this will assist in realization of our plans. . .I have an excellent idea. . . I shall induce anti-semites to liquidate Jewish wealth. . . The anti-semites will assist us thereby in that they will strengthen the persecution and oppression of Jews. The anti-semites shall be our best friends”.
-- From Herzl's Diary

Answer 7

I think what you brought out of this is the band-aid solution created by the world to hopefully cure the madness. To people are fighting... give them what they want.. instead of actually solving anything.

The bible? people of God? does it really matter? I think we should stop the killing, gun sale to warlords and settle this middle east business before we start looking into whether "Jews" are people of God or not...

Answer 8

Palestine was occupied by uk then they gave it to israel and gave them army and still feedback them to kill palestinians

if jews are still feeling bad about what happen in the second war give them land in germany not in my land

Answer 9

When my forefathers lived here we hunted when we needed to, we fished when we felt like it, we smoked some peyote when we felt the urge. Women cooked, cleaned and did most of the work. What makes you think that we want this mess that you immigrants created? p.s I am having more fun with those beads than Manhatten will ever be worth. p.s.s. you only think that you own the land, try not paying your taxes.......

Answer 10

Why not give the land back? Oh, that's easy. We don't want to. We like it.
Not nice reasoning, but honest reasoning.