You'll have to make up your own mind! I think there might be some truth in it, for many people over the world have resorted to cannibalism in times of great hardship and famine. And legends do have a starting point somewhere in time.
http://www.seanachaidh.org/sawney.htm
http://www.mysteriousbritain.co.uk/legends/sawney_bean.html
http://www.tartans.com/articles/famscots/sawneybean.html
http://www.forteantimes.com/articles/195_sawney2.shtml
The last link might best answer your question.
2006-07-07 14:42:52
·
answer #1
·
answered by Anonymous
·
1⤊
0⤋
The truth of the Sawney Bean legend is hard to confirm, but there are many factors which suggest the story is an 18th Century invention. It seems that the legend first saw print in the early 18th Century in the lurid broadsheets and chapbooks of the time. (See The Legend of Sawney Bean, London 1975 by Ronald Holmes for an excellent investigation into the myth.)These were all printed in England, but broadly match Nicholson's later rendering of the tale. The content of chapbooks was mainly invented and exaggerated stories about grisly deeds, executions, murders and other lurid accounts, aimed at shocking readers. They were evidently very popular and were certainly the forerunners of the Victorian Penny Dreadfuls.
According to Fiona Black in The Polar Twins, the tale was probably an English invention to denigrate the Scots, especially in the period of unrest that saw the Jacobite rebellion. There are however records of periods of famine, and some occurrences of cannibalism, in Scotland in the late 15th century.
Another sticking point is that there are no contemporary records from the time that even mention Sawney Bean. Although there are 'relatively' few records from the time, it is strange that such a high profile story, with the added involvement of the King James IV, has no historical evidence at all. There are also no records of the executions of the various innkeepers, and the disappearances of travellers in the Ayrshire area.
Like many legends said to be based on fact - where contemporary evidence does not exist - it is possible that a grain of truth exists somewhere in the story. It is also impossible to conclusively prove that there is no truth at all in the story. Personally I do not think that Bean existed, but the Ayrshire coastline is steeped in dark folklore, and the Bean legend may have its root in some far away bloody deed or gristly piece of folklore that has been long forgotten.
2006-07-11 12:55:57
·
answer #2
·
answered by starjessiegirl 6
·
0⤊
0⤋