This is Mariah's highest note and this is the World Record Holder's highest. compare their G7s?

Question

Some people said Mariah's highest note was G#7. The World Record Holder hits all Gs from G2 to G10. However I listened again to Mariah's G#7 and compared it to the record holders' G7. Mariah's was about 3 notes lower.

That means her g#7 is not really g#7, right?

Try listening,

This is Mariah's>>>>

http://youtube.com/watch?v=ZfFA6kr88eg&search=mariah%20national

This is the world record holder>>>>>>

http://www.georgiabrownmusic.com.br/index2.htm

compare and then tell me if I'm correct.
Please don't compare their careers, no doubt Mariah is the world's biggest selling artist

To rgreenfi: Moron, if that's screeching, she wouldn't be in the Guinness World Records

Answer 1

I don't know enough about music (octave range) and how to rate it.......but I DO OWN Mariah's first CD (Mariah Carey by Title)
and when she sings "Vision of Love" she hits at LEAST what she hit in the Star Spangled Banner, if not higher.

Have you ever heard "Loving You" by (the late) Minnie Ripperton?
She had a 6-octave range and I have to put it right up there with Mariah's range high..........as for your other video.......it's just amazing......

Thanks for the question and the links, I really enjoyed them!

Answer 2

Im sure Ive heard Mariah sing higher than this. There's no doubt that Georgia Brown's notes are higher, but frankly, her music sounds bloody awful.

Answer 3

I think they sound the same to me... I think the other girl's range was a little bit higher though.

But her music is HORRIBLE.

Answer 4

mabe the record holder was singing a g10. and why do you care sooo much?

Answer 5

That had to be the most annoying noise I've ever heard. Oh my God! That's not singing..it's screaching. Geez!!