I just got a deal where I trade Reggie Wayne for Rod Smith. Good Deal or Not?

Question

BTW: I already have Marvin Harrison.

Answer 1

Considering trading away Wayne is a decent idea since you have Harrison, but to do it for Smith is unwise. Wayne's value as a fantasy receiver is much greater than Smith's. Wayne actually had more receptions than Harrison last year, although Manning still looks Harrison's way once the end zome gets closer. And Smith is not the WR1 on his team anymore. Javon Walker looks to be at near full-strength by the start of the season and will be Plummer's main target.

My advice would be to look for someone that would be willing to trade for Wayne, but at a much higher value. Some guys to consider as equals in a deal would be Hines Ward, Darrell Jackson, Chris Chambers, or to drop down a small bit I like Donald Driver this year as well.

Either way, even if you are "stuck" with two receivers from the same team, they are both top 10 receivers and will both consistently outscore Rod Smith. Look for the trade in order to diversify your lineup, but look for a better one. Good luck!

Answer 2

Reggie Wayne is still improving as a WR and is in a good system with Peyton Manning throwing the pigskin to him. He may have to compete with Marvin Harrison, but that is not bad at all. Marvin will draw double coverage and Reggie should be able to reap the benefits.

Rod Smith has pretty much been supplanted as the #1 WR by Javon Walker. Smith will actually lose passes and yardage because of this acquisition. Also, Smith is getting close to the end of his career, so his productive value will drop.

No trade

Answer 3

With Marvin Harrison, you shouldn't have Wayne and him together on the same team because you can't count on them both having big games. With 2 playmakers on 1 team only 1 will have a good game and you will only get 1 good game. If you have 2 playmakers on 2 different teams, they can have big games because they are on seperate teams. Take the trade because Marvin and Reggie are good, but they are on the same team, Rod Smith is on a different team so you will get his and Marvins numbers instead of Marvin and nobody.

Answer 4

No way Reggie Wayne and Marvin Harrison together will get you tons of touchdowns because the colts won't have much of a running game this year with a rookie starting after they lost James.

Answer 5

i would not make the deal. In Arizona, the working interest would be utilized a good purchase with in basic terms a rookie and a prior fart QB, element is a reliable guy. Reggie Wayne could have an incredible year via loss of element in Indy, they're going to throw much greater, and this year Reggie ought to step up and take the #a million interest from the ever-becoming-older Marvin Harrison. on the different edge you have have been given 2 WR who're on communities who picked up an incredible 2nd selection in the process the low season, Steve in Carolina with Keyshaun on the different edge and Santana with ex-steeler Randel-El on the sphere. reliable luck

Answer 6

You can say that havin teammates is a bad havin teammates is a bad idea but u know dat that tandem is goin to produce. Reggie wayne is better dan rod smith jus for da simple fact of the 2 offenses. I had Boldin an Fitzgerald on my team last year but that didnt stop me from cashin in on both of them ; )

Answer 7

Rod Smith is in the decline. Jake Plummer MIGHT be replaced this year w/ Jay Cutler. I believe Plummer has a VERY short leash this year. With a rookie under center, I wouldn't bank on big rec'ing #'s from those Denver WRs.

Verdict: Stick w/ Wayne.

Answer 8

Nah... Reggie is already a superstar and has bigger upside than Rod Smith. Also, the colts may run less, so....

Answer 9

Wayne is definately more talented, but having 2 number one WRs is better than having teammates

Answer 10

they are both going to be good #2 recievers, but u gotta keep wayne....will have better stats