Need input about an upcoming evaluation; anyone have any ideas for handling a boss that is critical?

Question

She is really good at finding fault and holding a raise if she thinks you don't deserve it.

Answer 1

Make sure you go into the review prepared - have a list of your accomplishment since your last review. Show how you have exceeded your goals for the evaluation period.

Answer 2

When she is critcal -- ask her how she would have handled it different if she knew what you knew at the time! Just so you can get better at your position! That is a possitive spin!