does emma rossum really sing in the phantom of the opera or does she lip sync?

Answer 1

she is really singing. she has acually been part of opera since, she was like 7. here's some information on her :

Biography for
Emmy Rossum

Birth name
Emmanuelle Grey Rossum
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Nickname
Em
Emmy Grey
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Height
5' 8" (1.73 m)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mini biography
It would seem that 2004, the year of her 18th birthday, will be remembered as pivotal for Emmy Rossum due to her appearance in two very different films, The Day After Tomorrow (2004) and The Phantom of the Opera (2004). Emmy's performance in the latter film gained her a Golden Globe nomination, and should assure that she will be a memorable presence in many films to come.

Being born and raised in New York City provided Emmy with the perfect place to start her professional career. After passing an audition at the Metropolitan Opera when she was 7 years old, she performed in over 20 operas in six different languages at Lincoln Center, alongside figures such as Plácido Domingo and Luciano Pavarotti. She was directed by Franco Zeffirelli in "Carmen". She left the opera when she entered her teenage years, as she had grown too tall to perform as a child. Emmy also appeared in a Carnegie Hall presentation of "The Damnation of Faust".

In a change of venue, Emmy created the role of Abigail Williams in the daytime soap opera "As the World Turns" (1956) in 1999 and branched out in performances in the made-for-television movies Genius (1999) (TV) and The Audrey Hepburn Story (2000) (TV), in which she played the title character as a young teenager. Other television work included "Snoops" (1999), "Law & Order" (1990) and "The Practice" (1997).

Emmy made her theatrical feature debut in the indie Songcatcher (2000), which won the Special Jury Award for Outstanding Ensemble Performance at the Sundance Film Festival in January, 2000. Rossum received an Independent Spirit Award nomination in the category of Best Debut Performance for her performance as an Appalachian orphan. She played an aspiring songwriter (the title character) in the romantic comedy Nola (2003). Cast as the ill-fated daughter of a small-business owner in Clint Eastwood's Mystic River (2003), she projected an aura of innocence that made her tragic death memorable and heartbreaking. This was her first major studio film. After 6 months of filming her role as the fresh-faced but highly intelligent heroine of The Day After Tomorrow (2004) in Montreal, the 16 year old returned to New York and screen-tested for the role of Christine in The Phantom of the Opera (2004) in full costume and make-up and was finally selected for the part by Andrew Lloyd Webber after singing for him at his home. Although surprised to be chosen ahead of many better-known and older actresses considered for the part, the combination of her vulnerable, fragile beauty and fine, classically-trained singing voice ultimately proved that she was perfectly cast. In preparation for the role, she took ballet classes for two months and started polishing her singing. Emmy has commented that, in her approach to acting, she draws heavily upon her own experiences, so she visited locations in Paris and conjured up what she a terms "past memories" to draw upon in making her performance emotionally realistic. She stood on the roof of the Opera Garnier where Christine sings "All I Ask of You" and went underneath the opera house where there is actually a gloomy, dark lake. She studied Degas' paintings of ballerinas in the Musee d'Orsay to learn how to stand like one. Emmy attended the private Spence School in Manhattan through the 7th grade, and then finished high school using tutors and the Internet (through Stanford University). She is now enrolled at Columbia University and has already completed a course in art history, being inspired by her study of Degas in Paris

Answer 2

Emmy Rossum really did sing the part of Christine in The Phantom of the Opera. The only actor who did not was Minnie Driver who played Carlotta. Carlotta was dubbed by Margaret Preece, who had played Carlotta before on stage. However, you can hear Minnie sing on the POTO credits song, "Learn to Be Lonely."

Answer 3

She sings it, but they could have found someone better. I was Christine in a nearby production, and we actually had to move it to a larger theater because so many people were coming to see it! I should have gotten the part. She sucks. They actually all lip sync, but to their own voices, except for Minnie Driver playing Carlotta.

Answer 4

She really sings but often times with musicals on film they sing the soundtrack and put it into the film so they can record better. She may actually lipsinc for the scenes that have many people or large areas in it or maybe the whole movie but it's truely her voice.

And Carlata is Minnie Driver.

Answer 5

The only actor/actress who DID NOT sing was Minnie Driver...she lip synced her part

Answer 6

She sang it live in a studio and lip synced during the filming.

However, in the French and other international versions other singers were used.

Answer 7

Yes, she does actually sing in it. The only person who does not actually sing their part is Minnie Driver. Her's is dubbed in with someone else singing.

Answer 8

She actually sings, while Carlotta (Can't remember the actresses name) lip syncs.

Answer 9

She really sings. She went to some ritzy performing arts school in Manhattan.

Answer 10

No, Emmy really does sing in the movie!