perfect town or country?

Question

lets say i told you of a place where you could live,where you had a job paid by the value you gave to community,and that if you broke any law you would be thrown out,the laws drawn up by those who lived there,and politicians could only spend your money within frame work drawn up by the majority and could only be changed the same way,would you live there

Answer 1

it could work!

but only until you got human beings involved.

there are no utopias...

Answer 2

Well, first if I had a job where I will get the value of my work it will be a socialist government. Why not paying me for what I really have given to my community in exchange of my services? I think that is a lot more good for the rest of the community. In that way we all win.

Second, it isn't about breaking any law. But the laws that have the support of the common law and that have established a peaceful place to live and progress.

Given the power to a mayority to establish the use and amount of money to be used by the bureacrats is not a good idea either. It will only created a dictatorship of mayorities that will exclude all the minorities of the "paradise country". I prefer a country were we give the money with clear checks and balances and where everybody has the chance to decide which government program needs the money more. i.e. Security and enforcement of justice.

Answer 3

LMAO. And what happens when one of the residents dissents about a law drawn up by those who live there? And a job paid by the value I give to the community? Who pays the wages? The community? If so, where does the community get its money. No business will go in for this scheme, so they will not be paying these fantasy wages. And what about those people who are not pulling their weight in the community? They haven't broken any laws so they can't get kicked out. In short, no, I would not live there since it is a disaster waiting to happen.

Answer 4

Definitely!

Answer 5

yes