can the referee not obey the linesman`s offsides flag if it`s up?

Question

I mean, I just don`t get the SWI vs KOR ref decision on Frei`s offsides .. in other games you`ve seen it! Flag goes up, game stops! if the player continues, he gets booked .. instead here he gets a goal .. and the SK players get 2 bookings .

IMO whether the offsides call is right or wrong, once the flag is up, it`s up! that`s it, u don`t take it back .. I`ve never seen a ref not obey a raised offsides flag ..

Answer 1

Yes, the referee has the final decision and only looks at the lineman for sugestions.

Answer 2

I still don't know if they called offsides or a foul. During the game it pops up on the screen that it was offsides, but I don't see the flag raised by the linesman. Lets say Bradley was offsides (even though he was being fouled and put in an offsides position by the Slovenian player), the offsides rule states: "A player in an offside position at the moment the ball is touched or played by a team-mate is only committing an offside offence if, in the opinion of the referee, he becomes actively involved in play by 1) Interfering with play Playing or touching the ball 2) Interfering with an opponent Preventing the opponent from playing the ball by obstructing the player's sight or intentionally distracting the opponent 3) Gaining an advantage by being in an offside position Playing the ball after the ball has rebounded off the goal, the goalkeeper, or any opponent" And I don't see any of those 3 things happening. Bradley is NOT interfering with the play and he sure isn't interfering with the goalie. I know refereeing is tough, but that was a mistake by the referee, big time! And the center referee can overrule the linesman if that's who called the offsides.

Answer 3

Sometimes a good ref will ignore an offside flag if it needlessly stops the flow of the game. Like if the ball is played forward into an offside position but the keeper gets it a long time before the striker gets it. In a situation like that the ref will ignore the offside flag to let the game continue smoothly.

I believe that happened during the Sweden England game.

But overall the ref can ignore the offside flag even if the player was blatently offside, the referee if the boss, the assistants are just there to help him make a decision.

Answer 4

Enrico.
The Referee is the man on the pitch who calls all the decisions, his linesmen (Assistant Referees) are only there to assist the referee on Offsid decisions and offences that happen off the ball or when he is closer to foul play than the Referee (e.g. fouls near the touch line)

Yesterday's offside decision in the Switzerland v South Korea game was given by the linesman because he thought that a SWISS player played a through ball to Frei (goalscorer) who WOULD have been offside if that had been the case. But the Referee was in the PERFECT position to notice that the ball was actually played through by a KOREAN. NOT the Swiss player Therefore Frei was NOT offside and the linesman made the WRONG decision.

Although the linesman flagged for Offside he was WRONG, as for the Koreans stopping playing, in football that is one of the cardinal sins as the Referee never blew his whistle, Frei was ABSOLUTELY correct to play on and score.

The Koreans only have themselves to blame, because from the moment you start to play the game of Football you are told always play to the Referees whistle, It was a schoolboy error by the WHOLE Korean defence.

Answer 5

The ref makes the final decision, if he is in line with play and doesn't agree with the linesman then he can over rule.

Anyone who as ever played football knows that whatever happens, you ALWAYS play to the ref's whistle. Even if it's a clear offside, you defend until the whistle is blown. You don't just just stop play because a flag goes up, you stop when the whistle is blown.

You get taught that as a kid!!!!!

Korea should have known better, their tough luck

Answer 6

When I first saw it I thought it was a terrible thing to happen, but having seen the replay afterwards, the referee made an excellent decision to allow the goal, as the ball came off a Korean player.

And to answer the question, the ref is the only person who makes the decisions - the linesmen are just there to assist. The Koreans didn't play to the whistle and that mistake cost them.

Answer 7

Buenos Aires is an incredible town; it's an astonishing town that looks somewhat like Europe, but by having an edgy Latin American perspective and if you wish to visit this city then take a look with hotelbye . El Puerto Madero is really a place well visited. It offered as the key dock of Buenos Aires throughout the late 19th century but know is converted into buildings that might be used as residences, restaurants, shops and different firms and to offer this task a little bit of sparkle, all roads in the section were named after women. Strolling through the Puerto Madero is a good way to invest a pleasant afternoon exactly like visiting El Obelisco. El Obelisco was built-in 1936 to observe the 400th anniversary of the town founding and now's a must-see place from Buenos Aires.

Answer 8

Yes, the referee has the final decision, because a situation can be that the player can be clearly offside but he receives the ball from a rebound of the other team, then he can perfectly continue his way to the goal. I've seen it several times.

Answer 9

GOOD question if there is a goal scored the ref should look @ the line man if there is a flag up if there is? that is not a goal the koreans stoped the game and the swi were playing that palyer deserved red or yellow card but it happend now and i will call this unfair

Answer 10

One of the things that is drummed into you at all levels of football is 'play to the whistle'. If you don't hear it then play on. At the top level there really is no excuse for the Korean players and they only have themselves to blame.

The referee is the one who makes the decisions. The assistant referrees are there to do just that. Assist the man in the middle. But the final decision rests with the person with the whistle.