Is a public defender just as good as a hired attorney? Do they try to get a good deal for the defendent?

Question

My brother does not have enough money to hire an attorney. He's going to be appointed a public defender, but I'm nervous that he/she may not be as competent as a hired attorney.

Thank you all for your great answers!

Answer 1

They might not be as competent...this is true. But all attorneys take an oath to represent their clients to the best of their ability. Their competency will depend on their experience...and their passion. Your brother would be smart to be very proactive...participate as much as he can..give as much information, ask as many questions as he can..help in his defense.

Answer 2

This Site Might Help You.

RE:
Is a public defender just as good as a hired attorney? Do they try to get a good deal for the defendent?
My brother does not have enough money to hire an attorney. He's going to be appointed a public defender, but I'm nervous that he/she may not be as competent as a hired attorney.

Answer 3

For the best answers, search on this site https://shorturl.im/lakcb

Ok let's answer your question first, public defenders suck. Hire a private attorney. If you've got money then the good thing is some of the best attorneys in the country have Florida licenses. Hell, maybe you can get Casey anthonys lawyer. If you don't have money look for a decent attorney for an affordable price. But really stretch your budget to find the best one you can afford. Now, I bet you can work up a plea deal for a shorter sentence if you are willing to turn in your criminal co-workers. To prepare for court buy a nice black or grey suit with a matching tie and belt. Buy new shampoo, brush your teeth, get a nice professional looking hair cut. Trim your nails, take out any earings, unless they're the big ones that make a giant hole. Cover any tats. If you have tats on your head do your best to grow your hair out to a long enough length to cover them. Shave. Don't wear any axe or cologne into court, get any teeth repaired that need it. Go to the dentist for a cleaning. Buy nice dress shoes, add a subtle watch to your look, not a giant clunky peice of silver. Pray to god.

Answer 4

Are Public Defenders Good

Answer 5

You received a public defender because you were assumed to not be financially able to afford an attorney. Since you are now apparently financially able, and you seem to want to, go for the attorney--especially since now you are not eligible to use the PD's services. PD's do not suck. In many cases they know the courts, judges and laws better than private attorneys.

Answer 6

Public defenders and assistant public defenders usually try their best, but they generally do tend to be at the beginning of their careers (or very, very dedicated to the cause of fairness). They also tend to have heavy caseloads, particularly in big cities, and be frustrated that they can't give each case the attention it deserves. They work harder than lawyers in private practice and don't make nearly as much money.

I had a good friend who used to work in the public defender's office. He had gone into law to help juvenile Latinos get a fair sshake. After a few years, he was burnt out, and he realized that if he wanted to really help kids he needed to reach them before they got into trouble. So, he took a huge pay cut and became a teacher.

Answer 7

You can see by yourself at the following https://tr.im/861peoplesearch please have a name ready. A Criminal background checks demonstrates the inconsistencies between a candidate's statements and facts from unbiased resources which include offender plus city law courts, former recruiters, schools, plus federal government divisions.

District Criminal conviction records Check - offence criminal convictions data if any, misdemeanor or infraction data can also surface
Training Proof - days of presence plus commencement, diplomas or accreditation received are often the most widespread - majors trained in, GPA, in addition to honors attained can also show
Recruitment Record Confirmation - an applicant’s occupation title, tenure, reasons behind departing as well as eligibility for rehire are routine - wage could be provided
Social Security Number Check - titles and also addresses associated with a specific Social Security Number would be the frequently documented - the statement may also demonstrate in case a Social Security Number is good, when it had been given, and also just where it was given
Automobile Record - the driver's license status - traffic violations, failures to show up, along with unsettled fees could display in the document
Nationalized General population Details along with Police warrants Look for - outstanding police warrants ( frequently these supplied with regard to extraditable crimes )
Sex Culprit Computer registry Check - reveals in the event that an job candidate can be recorded being a charged sex culprit.

Answer 8

Private attorneys suck just as bad, all they are interested in is taking your money. Take the court appointed attorney, they try to win as many cases as they can to defend there reputation and so they can move on to bigger and better things, they care about winning cases, might as well save the money and your brother. If he's guilty he better take a plea bargain, if not make sure to tell him to take a Jury trial (unless it's a sexual or drug offense).

This is not legal advice only my opinion.

Answer 9

They are equally schooled, trained and compotent! However, the public defender has 1000 clients to the retained attorneys 1. They dont have the time to even care about their client much less dedicate time to their defense. Take out a loan....sell your soul...whatever, but only if he didn't do what he is charged with. If its just cut a deal....theres no diff!

Answer 10

PD's can be good representation but you are still their "boss". They will often try to get you to plea bargain so they can collect their $200 and go home. I had one once and he was going to plea me to 6 months, I told him I'd do every day he did. He got the message. I told him I wanted probation, I'd give the DA "his" guilty plea (it was an election year) but I was going to go home today. I got it. Don't be a jerk, but be firm. I don't know how serious this crime is but every day in jail is serious. They make people sicker, so avoid them at all costs. But if probation is granted do what they tell him to do. And it is often difficult but do it anyway. And do not re-offend. If the circumstances in your brother's life seem to point to re-offending, get help. If he is an addict, which will turn anyone into a criminal, get him in rehab and another and another and another, until the problem is rectified. Good luck.