New Orleans & Posse Comitatus?

Question

How can there be military (albeit National Guard) performing law enforcement duties in the U.S.?

Answer 1

Because the National Guard was set up to get around Posse Comitatus by being fully funded by the state they are there to protect. They may get federal money from grants and such, but the grant money goes to the state, not the military unit. Then the STATE itself funds the units needs. As a military unit fully funded by the state, and for the state, is is lawful for the Governor of the state to order them into civilian action, not as an Army unit, but as a deputized law enforcement unit under the control of the Governor's office. Or whatever other reason he needs them. (For example, he/she can order medical personel into the field and set up medical facilities for civilians.) FEDERAL troops, such as a Marine detachment, or a Regular Army (or RA) detachment could not participate in these same actions except as in a supporting role only, as is the case with the federal troops supporting the local and federal law enforcement agencies along the Mexican border. They have no arrest authority, but use sophisticated techniques and sheer manpower to support those who do.

Answer 2

They were requested by the Governor of the State. Their Primary duty is to assist in the rescue of Amercian citizens. I'm glad they are there to assist law enforcement and the common person from being victims of theft.

Answer 3

They are part of our military. They are even serving in Iraq and other countries. I haven't heard of marshal law being established though. The police need assistance in the area due to the violence. I am pretty glad to know they would be there to protect me from thugs and murderers.

Answer 4

Uh, it is an emergency zone. NO is a hell-hole and needs some serious enforcement.

Answer 5

its a national emergency