Should I take this job?

Question

I am currently a product manager at a growing start-up software company which may have some potential to become acquired or public in 2-4 years.

I have an offer to become a director at this company but also have an offer to be a product manager at an established, big Internet company in a product manager position.

I will get broader experience at the big Internet company but staying at my current company will give me great managerial experience.

What should I do?

Answer 1

I love how everyone is talking about money because no one ever thinks about the environment in which one works in. Money isn't everything unless that's what motivates you but one thing to think about besides which job gives you the most money or most experience is which company will treat you better? Sometimes, just being in a good environment is all it takes to stay at a low paying job. It's hard to go to work everyday hating your work, hating your coworkers, and hating everything else around you including but not limited to the color of your stapler. Another thing too is growth. Which company can you be in that you could one day be the CEO? unless of course you don't care about that or happiness, then just go with the money and the higher paying position.

Answer 2

You will have to look at whether or not either of the jobs will require you to relocate and which has a higher pay rate and which has a better benefit package.

Generally, managers will be paid a higher rate and you might get more benefits and bonuses. Also you will have seniority over the other people.

If you go to the new company you will be at the bottom of the list, that means if there are any cut backs you will be one of the first to go, no seniority.

I think you should take the promotion at the company you are already with.

Answer 3

Not sure how old you are, but it would be good to get more experience where you are, now. You will be more seasoned to take on more responsibility at another company in the future. Even if it's not at the one you just received the offer from. Always remember, the grass IS NOT always greener on the other side. If after a few years,you feel the need for a change, and of course, more money, then go for it!!! Good luck to you!

Answer 4

Go for the director position. If your company get's acquired, there's a chance you can stay on as a director. BUT, if you're not able to, at least you're now an "Experienced Director". Both situations are a win for you.

Product Managers are schmucks compared to Directors.

Answer 5

First, research your "facts" deeper. What are the chances your present company will be acquired? Where will your offer stand then? Will a take-over be likely? In the new company, will you be liked and actually assigned more responsibilities and more job diversity? Then enter other factors: money, benefits, commute, work environment and philosophy, colleagues. See with all that where you will be more fulfilled. Chose that job.

Answer 6

I think that you will be wise to stay at the current job, and build your managerial experience.
It would help you greatly, considering, you want to go to the top, and this will be your closest step to that.

If you are sure they will be acquired soon, then you will be right where you need to be, and want have to spend a lot of time proving yourself, like you might in the other offer.

Answer 7

My feeling is that you should go with the big internet company. You won't stay there forever, but the experience will be very valuable.

Answer 8

What will help you more in the long run broader experience or managerial one?You have the answer!

Answer 9

Things to consider....money and time. Which one will you make more money at working the least hours. I don't know your lifestyle, (kids, etc.) but if you have to work around another schedule, which company will allow you to have more flexability? Good Luck!!!

Answer 10

Select the position that will allow for future growth and potentionally greater salary.