Should I propose thus trate, I'll trade Vick and Brees for Young and Lienart?

Question

I'm trading Vick and Brees

Answer 1

Are you outta your mind!?!? Two guaranteed starters who put up guaranteed numbers EVERY week for two pine riders? Uhhhh...no. Besides, Young won't put up any quality FFL numbers for at least three years.
If you're in a keeper league, drop Vick and pick up Leinert--his future's golden with those receivers and a stud RB. Young is iffy at best, and Vick--while a human highlight reel--has never put up big FFL points.

Answer 2

OMG! I wish I was on the other side of the trade. Of course rookies are selling high, but for way too much! Don't trade starters for back ups. Well Young is probably going to be starter, and Lienhart will start before the end of the season, but it isn't worth it.

MAYBE, consider it, ONLY if you're in a keeper league.

Answer 3

Young and Lienart wont get many touches, and areent going to put up numbers. Vick and Brees will put up good numbers.

Answer 4

Hell no. Vick and Brees are still pretty young and they're proven commodities. Young and Leinart may be great but history says that one of them (at least) will be a mediocre to poor player.

Answer 5

Vick--Starter, Brees--Starter....Young--bench, Lienart--bench....HMMMM???

Answer 6

In two words : HELL NO! You dont trade to vets for two rookies before the football season starts. Espically rookie QB's.

Answer 7

No. Why trade players you know will put up numbers this year for guys who may not even start?

Answer 8

ARE YOU OUT OF YOUR MIND? Let me guess you picked Reggie Bush 1st.

Answer 9

heck no

Answer 10

no