What do you think about laws being harsh with people selling burned cds?

Question

What I want to know is why do they waste their time in little things like this. I dont think it not wrong but its not like they are killing. I saw in the news the caught 11 people selling cds and movies burned and next to this was several case in which people had gotten stabbed. Guess what no arrest were made. My brother last year almost got killed and they came out saying the guy who did this to him was the victim. My brother was almost dead and did not even know the guy. Well the point is whats up with the laws. Why they dont get the real bad guys and get of course get after this ones too but not as bad as the are. Hopefully in the future the find the killers and not the cd burners.

Answer 1

I have given this subject some thought over the past few years. My answer in a nutshell is that I WOULD NOT GO OUT AND BUY A MUSIC CD OR VIDEO DVD at the price they are sold at. By downloading it for free or purchasing it form someone who has done so - for cheap - I am doing something I would not have done because the price and quality (artistic quality) did NOT MESH. IF for some reason I found the movie or cd to contain a lot of useful stuff and I wanted a QUALITY copy, then I would go out and buy it! This in a sense results in the opposite of what the WHITE COLLAR THIEVES known as the "MUSIC INDUSTRY" are/is telling you. The artist IN MANY CASES gets VERY LITTLE for their creativity, perhaps 5% or LESS of the gross sales price! You are not paying for art, you are generally paying for managers to get richer. So I say screw-em! Pay the artist directly. Have the artist burn cds and I will pay them a couple of bucks for their talent.

Answer 2

I think those using the work of others to profit SHOULD be punished. It's stealing. As someone else said - when people aren't caught for other crimes it's not because of tracking down copyright infringement. That's totally unrelated. The issue of burning and selling is a big one because the person who did the work gets nothing. I recently blew the whistle on someone who listed a cd by a friend of mine for $1,000 online -a price my friend would get *nothing* from. He did the recording; he wrote the songs on it and he gets part of what his cds sell for. The greed of people copying it and keeping all the $ themselves is punishable and should be.
If someone reached in your wallet and took $100 a day from you wouldn't you want it stopped? What if it was $500? $50? $1,000? The price doesn't change the fact it's taking something that is yours and doesn't belong to the thief.
It's just as much so taking music and selling it. Copy a CD and sell it for $5-10 nothing of it goes to the artist.

Answer 3

It's flawlessly authorized to resell song which you've bought wherever. This will have to be no exceptional than if you purchase a commercially pressed CD within the retailer, after which resell it a couple of years later at a storage sale or a consignment store. Now, in the event you had been to have saved the ones songs for your laptop and made copies of the ones to promote to a purchaser, then you definately might probably get in authorized concern if the Feds or the R.I.A.A particularly desired to hassle pursuing the trouble badly ample. But you'll be able to be definite there may be ample fair doubt right here that you are good underneath their radar. Just ensure you inform someone who questions you that you just did, actually absolutely *switch* all the ones songs to these CDs, and also you didn't hold any copies for your self. However, despite the fact that I significantly doubt you can get into any authorized disorders with the civil professionals, final I checked eBay has a personal coverage towards you auctioning selfmade burnt CDs until you are the long-established writer of the songs or program on them. If that purchaser insists on reporting the trouble, at worst you might lose your eBay account. I could write again to him and demand how your movements had been flawlessly authorized, but when selfmade CDs are a situation for him (and so they honestly *are* much less long lasting and of typically poorer fine than industrial CDs) then you are going to deliver him a whole refund for the ones (and simplest the ones) CDs, adding a couple of greenbacks additional to make amends for delivery. Then wish for the satisfactory. If he reasons you to lose your account, you'll be able to begin up a brand new one, you can simply lose your entire accrued suggestions. Just subsequent time, learn and obey the eBay purchaser recommendations extra cautiously.

Answer 4

that sucks about your brother, but the reason they didnt catch the people responsible for the stabbing isnt because they were out catching people selling burned cd's. There are different sections of the police department that handle different crimes, and you can be assured they have more people working homicide than piracy. however, as an independant artist myself, when people burn cd's it's like they are stealing money from us. Many artists and musicians can afford it, since they have a lot of people that will buy their cd. but independant artists are the ones who really suffer because of this since they rely on the sales of these cds to live as opposed to major artists who get a salary from a record company.

Answer 5

the laws have to be harsh toas thats the only alternative left to the govt. to avoid sale of pirated or burned cds. its unfair to the people who have worked in bringing out these movies and if you just sell it by burning the cds people will watch it at home rather thanthe theatres so the movie as well as cinema hall people will lose out business. sorry about your brother though he shouldnt have done this