Hypothetical writing question?

Question

If a story you wish to write can be envisioned like a movie within your mind, do you measure your talent by how accurately you describe the movie with your writing?

Answer 1

Hi there. That is one of the BEST questions I've seen on this forum so far. The answer I would offer is, "Yes, think of your story as a movie, but don't get bogged down in too many details."

Dialogue is what carries a movie--that, and the action that goes with the dialogue. That's why actors get paid what they do--their work makes or breaks the movie.

The same thing applies in a book. The main characters MUST carry the action and present the story without it sounding like you are just telling a story. The most important aspect of movie making is called "Suspension of Disbelief" which means those watching the movie never have a reason to say to themselves, "This scene (or character, or action) is a crock--it could never really happen this way."

You have to do the same thing in your writing. Suspend DISbelief and that means your readers believe the story. When that happens, dude, you have MADE it as a writer.

How do I know all this? My newest book was written from the very first page with the idea that it would make a terrific movie, along the lines of Braveheart meets Lord of the Rings. And guess what? A Hollywood producer told me that is exactly what he was thinking about as he read my book. Now it's wait and see if it actually becomes a movie.

Anyway, I hope this helps. Good luck with your writing.

Jon F. Baxley (Author, Editor, Ghostwriter and Proofreader)
THE SCYTHIAN STONE
THE BLACKGLOOM BOUNTY

(For a FREE copy of The Scythian Stone eBook or a full color, four chapter illustrated demo of The Blackgloom Bounty, email me at [e-mail]).

Answer 2

Accuracy is not talent. All the detail in the world will not save a boring story. Write your story and let others tell you what parts they liked and what parts they didn't like. draw from their input to build on your strengths and bolster your weaknesses.
Talent is only measured by the desire of others to see, read, hear or experience your work. Get writing, the stories won't write themselves.

Answer 3

I would say so.