Was this a good trade for me?

Question

I gave up Rafael Furcal and Victor Martinez and I got miguel Tejada.
Here is my lineup before the trade also if the trade gets approved who should I pickup for catcher:C V. Martínez
(Cle - C)
1B L. Berkman
(Hou - 1B,LF,RF)
2B M. Cuddyer
(Min - 1B,2B,3B,RF)
3B D. Wright
(NYM - 3B)
SS R. Furcal
(LAD - SS)
CI P. Fielder
(Mil - 1B)
MI J. Barfield
(SD - 2B)
IF S. Casey
(Pit - 1B)
LF C. Floyd
(NYM - LF)
CF Sh. Green
(Ari - CF,RF)
RF Á. Ríos

Answer 1

yes..you need a bat. Any time you can get Tejada reasonably, I'd go for it. I feel it's a waste to use an early pick on a C. Pick 'em up and drop 'em. My current Cs are McCann, Willingham, Estrada, Varitek. They get injured quite often. Right now Napoli and Martin are hot.
Furcal is only hitting .240 ..Martinez, last I checked was around.200..for a cleanup hitter like Miguel Tejada is a sweet deal.
Now go and get the SBs you need. Maybe figgins is available!

Answer 2

Not a good deal. Normally I am all for two-for-one deals but Martinez is just as good as Tejada, and you tossed in Furcal.

Answer 3

I hope you have another catcher. tejada might get you more pop that furcal but unless you have a better option than martinez, i think it was a bad deal.

Answer 4

Its an OK trade. Since you traded away the best catcher in the Majors, you are going to lose a lot of production at catcher.

Answer 5

Obviously

Answer 6

Yes it was. V. Mart is not doing so well. If you need another catcher, get either McCann or Johnny Estrada.

Answer 7

no!
since you made the trade try to go for michael barrett or josh willingham to replace martinez!

Answer 8

Yes.

Answer 9

Bad trade.U were better off without that trade.

Answer 10

not sure, i would've asked for a catcher, cause good catchers are hard to come by.