Rock or Pop?

Question

Most Rock bands write their own songs, perform live on stage for hours together

Most Pop bands have got song writers and they do lip sync on live shows..pop is just fashion these days....

Rock is all about talent!!!

What do you think?

Answer 1

It is obvious that you, like myself, are into music as a form of expression, as a form of art. That's why you love rock music, because pure rock isn't about popularity or about commercial successs. It is about expressing your deepest feelings through your songs, baring your innermost thoughts through your musical mastery and skill.

Yes, there have been some bands that have utilized rock as a channel to gain popularity and commercial succes, but such outfits have not lasted, confirming that only those bands who actually remain faithful to their musical integrity are those who have been and will be around for decades.

As for pop, well, it is a totally different animal. I hate pop in general, especially the kind they show on MTV and VH1, it is simply disgusting. But hey, there are some people out there that could care less about skill or musical depth. They are contempt and pleased with the lyrics and catchy rhythms they are offered through these songs. These are the people who buy CD-singles, download a lot of crappy songs only to erased them next week because they either got sick of them or the songs are not hip anymore. Pop music was designed for this kind of people. Although I have to say, in every decade there have been a couple of good pop songs that have outlasted time, but other than that, I think American Idol, its anchors and all of its audience, let it be live or televised, should be thrown to the lions or at least be flamed in public.

Answer 2

When the great rock bands started writing their own material, that's when they defined themselves and came into their own.
They knew the strengths and weaknesses of each band member and could write songs which reflected their best attributes while downplaying their flaws. Without talent, for example: musicianship, songwriting skills and good singers, few rock bands can last. Even the punk bands with limited talent still had to come up with material and a unique sound plus the chemistry that occurs when the right people get together. You're correct about when a band clicks after performing for hours live and also jamming during rehearsals and in the studio.

Answer 3

I am a rock fan at heart, and rock, it's something that you can relate to and bang your head to.
When I see some of those pop people on TV doing there 'thing' in the music industry, I kind of look at the people in the audience and go "Wouldn't it be boring to sit there and watch?"
To me, the people in the pop industry they just sing the lyrics and get off stage. They don't seem to listen to it, and only choose material that is going to elevate their career. The music that they write, you can't relate to it, because it's all written like this.
eg:
You can do it girl! Just keep on walking!
Get through the day with your head up high-igh-igh YEAH!
You can do it, just a little longer. . .

It's telling you to get over you silly problems, and you can't relate to it the way you can with rock which is written like this.

eg:
Mistakes, that you made, are leaking onto another of the same
species
Mistakes that you made, have destroyed what we feel and what we do. . .

You get my drift? I am not really good at explaining it at all but whatever.

By the way. Don't dis me for my crappy spontanious lyric writing.
Cheers. Lol!

Answer 4

rock, i love seeing people with real talent perform on stage. coz they are the ones with real stories to tell. though sometimes, rock music could give me a headache but it's okay. pop, most of the time, is shallow. sheesh! sometimes, they just don't make sense. all they ever do is flaunt their bodies to sell their music. what is that?

Answer 5

cutting-side cases Rock and Roll by using Queen. God Gave Rock 'N' Roll to You II by using Kiss, a redesigning of God Gave Rock 'N' Roll to You by using Argent. Sultans of Swing by using Dire Straits. Rock and Roll song by using Chuck Berry.

Answer 6

ROCK!!! They can play their instruments and sing too. They have to do more than pop-artists too. They have to be able to play guitar and sing at the same time (like Children Of Bodom's Alexi Laiho does). Pop-stars can't smile and walk at the same time.

Answer 7

I think that rock is really great,but for a concert to or for live performance in general.But for dancing and relaxing is Pop definitely better!

Answer 8

Sprinsteen!

Answer 9

pop

Answer 10

I would love POP!