雙重國籍 兵役問題

Question

我現在有美國護照, 不過我是在17歲出台灣後才拿到的. 有人類似情況成功回台灣又出來的嗎? 我有聽說有人用美國護照照樣被扣留, 但是也有人說短期沒關係, 有人有經驗嗎? 你們有沒有把你們的中文名字留著在護照上(英文)? 我很想知道境管局是如何從外國護照知道那些人是役男? 謝謝

Answer 1

我和你一樣的時間出來~~
我今年暑假第一次拿美國謢照進台灣，說真的超緊張的。
因為我有雙重國籍
之前我都拿台灣謢照+在學證明回去兩個月
因為我之前也看過很多在yahoo知識上發表的文章，也聽說要碰碰運氣之類的。
不過，我覺得沒有想像中這麼恐佈啦！
我是拿美國謢照進出的(停留20天)
如果你打算停留不超過30天
只要填入境表格(在飛机上會發給你)
你只要寫謢照上的英文名字, 千萬不要寫中文名字+身份字號(因為我沒有寫上去，反正就照你美國謢照上面來寫就好)
然後在台的地址，你就隨便寫一個hotel的名字就好。一樣寫英文
我記得我在排隊要過海關的時候，有一對情侶也是台灣人，他們也拿美國謢照入境，他們的來台地址只寫hotel。後來海關人員問他們那裡的hotel？他們說台北，後來海關人員就幫他們寫上去，所以你就好要寫那個城市
最後是把整個hotel的名字寫上去。
總之，我進去和出來，海關人員都沒有問我什麼，通常如果被問，我也是聽到是問你要停留多久，就這樣子。
當然風險還是有，只不過我覺得如果你只停留不到一個月，你也沒有去辦停留台灣的簽證，更何況你拿的是美國謢照，意思就是你只是來觀光，沒什麼大問題。如果真的還不放心，我這次還隨身帶了美國在台協會的連絡電話和地址，萬一你被海關扣留之類的，可以請他們來協助。這是我朋友告訴我的。
我知道很多人都會擔心，包括我在內。不過，我也成功的回來了。希望我的回答你會滿意。

Answer 2

The gentlemen above have not a clue what they are talking about.
Visitor specifics in the visa application process is often relegated in computer systems--the correlation between your dual nationalities, however, are not present, nor are they delineated; implicating that research on the their part, must be appropriated BEFORE they can identify your taiwanese identity.

Loophole-- The purpose of 'insisting' that you've renounced your Taiwanese nationality during the Visa application process, is to delay, and hopefully squander their efforts in retrieving your counterpart. Just inform your visa application officer, when asked, that you have renounced your taiwanese citizenship immediately when you recieved your USA passport. Offer them a name of similar pronounciation but different characters, and you'll be fine.
Only the USA government legally retains information of your dual nationality, on the premise that your taiwanese social security number and passport has been left unused and has subsequently expired. Furthermore, a renunciation of existing nationalities will not be implicated in your profile. Hence, the said loophole.

International exhibition of your file is contingent upon your criminal records in the US. if you've committed grand larceny, or grand theft autor, and wish to return to taiwan, for example, the chances of taiwanese authorities accesing your canadian profile, and thereby your taiwanese nationality, is absolute.

suffice it to say, your file should be a clean slate, and if your visa application goes accordingly to MYprovided responses, you will be recognized as a foreigner, with an existing, but long renounced taiwanese nationality.

I speak from personal experience, as I am employed in US/CAN and have just recently returned from four months stay (consisting of one trip to hong kong for visa renewal).

2006-10-17 06:05:40 補充：
No! US landing visa precludes the need for a visitors visa, yes, but it also raises curiosity, and a subsequent background check. the purpose of the visitor's visa is to serve as a confirmation of your background information, once
your're cleared, your safe.

2006-10-17 06:09:02 補充：
值星官--this is your first warning, further inappropriate, fallacious advice regarding taiwanese military service and dual nationalities, will be reported to administrators at Yahoo Answers.

Answer 3

反正有個心理準備吧
看BILLY講的都合邏輯
but
shi t happens
you never know

2006-10-29 14:44:25 補充：
I love the armed forces of the republic of china

regarding taiwanese military service? f-u my pal

Answer 4

記得回來時，就落地簽證就好了，在入境表不要填你的中文姓名，只填你的英文姓名。短期的落地簽證30天，要是要回台灣超過30天，記得就當天去香港或澳門去蓋個出境章，晚上又可以回來台灣繼續簽落地30天!在入境表格上的弟只填你祖母或姑姑伯父家，絕對不能填你的戶籍地。要準備來回的機票，跟海關確實的說要來台幾天(說10天也會蓋30天啦!!)台灣護照收好，不要把它跟你的美國護照放在一起，不要很白木的拿兩本護照給海關!! 入境理由要寫探親或觀光，推說你來看你美國台灣的同學。可以都跟海關說英文，不必說台灣國語。不要擔心，我跟我很多朋友之前都是這樣出入境，那種被扣押的就是很白木的人!! 亂填戶籍地，或是亂填中文名子。人家問你有沒台灣護照就說沒有，之前拿美國時就放棄了，海關也不會亂寫啥!

2006-10-13 17:22:22 補充：
agree to 值星官shxt happens, 本來役男回台就是要賭一把，第一次最可怕，之後就習慣成自然了!! 不過要是真的運氣差，那就請你去剃頭當兵吧!!