自從1967以來，每年選出一首『最完美』歌曲？

Question

應該沒有人真的去選吧＠＠
滾石雜誌日前推出了一個榜單慶祝他們不知甚麼碗糕的紀念：
http://www.rollingstone.com/news/coverstory/1000thsongs/1/most_excellent_songs_of_every_year_since_1967
列表如下，請問搖滾區的同好覺得這分榜單如何呢？
（2005難道真的沒有甚麼好歌嗎？）

1. The RollingStones, \"Dandelion\" (1967)
2. The Monkees, \"What Am I Doing Hangin\' Round\" (1968)
3. The Beatles, \"Don\'t Let Me Down\" (1969)
4. Sly and theFamily Stone, \"Everybody Is A Star\" (1970)
5. James Brown, \"I\'m a Greedy Man\" (1971)
6. David Bowie, \"Starman\" (1972)
7. New York Dolls, \"Trash\" (1973)
8. Roxy Music, \"TheThrill Of It All\" (1974)
9. Millie Jackson, \"There You Are\" (1975)
10. Lou Reed, \"CrazyFeeling\" (1976)
11. Television, \"Marquee Moon\" (1977)
12. Public ImageLtd., \"Public Image\" (1978)
13. Joy Division, \"Disorder\" (1979)
14. Mission of Burma, \"Academy Fight Song\" (1980)
15. Depeche Mode, \"Dreaming Of Me\" (1981)
16. New Order, \"Temptation\" (1982)
17. Prince, \"LittleRed Corvette\" (1983)
18. Husker Du, \"Something I Learned Today\" (1984)
19. Madonna, \"DressYou Up\" (1985)
20. Jesus and MaryChain, \"My Little Underground\" (1986)
21. Eric B. andRakim, \"I Know You Got Soul\" (1987)
22. Big Daddy Kane, \"Ain?t No Half Steppin\'\"(1988)
23. Morrissey, \"TheLast of the Famous International Playboys\" (1989)
24. Nirvana, \"Sliver\"(1990)
25. Pavement, \"Debris Slide\" (1991)
26. Suede, \"The Drowners\" (1992)
27. Bikini Kill, \"Rebel Girl\" (1993)
28. Guided ByVoices, \"Gold Star For Robot Boy\" (1994)
29. Oasis, \"Live Forever\" (1995)
30. Pulp, \"Common People\" (1996)
31. The Notorious B.I.G., \"Mo Money Mo Problems\" (1997)
32. Sleater-Kinney, \"Get Up\" (1998)
33. The Rondelles, \"Shanghai Surprise\" (1999)
34. Hefner, \"We LoveThe City\" (2000)
35. The White Stripes, \"Fell In Love With A Girl\" (2001)
36. Interpol, \"Roland\" (2002)
37. Missy Elliott, \"Let Me Fix My Weave\" (2003)
38. The Hold Steady, \"Killer Parties (2004)
39. FranzFerdinand, \"Do You Want To\" (2005)
40. Yeah YeahYeahs, \"Cheated Hearts\" (2006)

Answer 1

這完全是主觀意識吧
沒有一首歌是真正完全被所有人認同的
跟環境也有關係
歌好不好是一回事
可能它在某些年代代表的意義
才是最重要的

Answer 2

滾石雜誌自從轉變成全方位娛樂雜誌後

越來越糟糕了

去看Revolver啦

Answer 3

感覺蠻遜的

Answer 4

這名單好主觀啊...

Answer 5

沒錯，挺意外Oasis Suede Pulp Morrissey都榜上有名（但卻沒有radiohead），90中美國樂團明明也是百花齊放阿

Answer 6

感覺蠻黑black 蠻Alternative ,British的 頗意外地