請問英文辯論

Question

請問我們要辯論
主題是The difference between Taiwan and China
我該怎麼做
我是支持統一的一方
或者我是支持分裂的一方
要怎麼辯會比較好呢
我覺得題目好模糊哦
有哪邊可以查資料是關於這些的嗎??
我都找不到耶
我覺得這個題目比較像演講的題目...
好難哦
可以請英文很厲害的告訴我嗎
有哪些重點是必須要說的
可以列出來給我瞧一瞧嗎??

ps.拜託小白不要來 我也知道作業不能在這邊做 但是我是求救 好嗎!?謝謝

Answer 1

the supporting uniting the two:
1. mention that we are all chinese, world is gonna be ours if we unite.
2. the only way to improve both sides is to unite and fight the future together. ( from other countries invasion)

for dividing the two:
1. political stand is the big reason, everybody has the right to choose who they want to be , and everybody has a free mind, goverment should not control any of it.
2. china is going to bomb taiwan no matter what, why surrender?


about where you can find references:
i think if you can get some american newspaper or some issues of times, that's be good, search it a big, i am sure they talked about this in times a while ago.

here is some websites
http://newton.uor.edu/Departments&Programs/AsianStudiesDept/china-taiwan.html

http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qa3680/is_199904/ai_n8827649

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/1782759.stm

also, when you search, search on english websites, not chinese ones, this way, it'd be easier for you to have the evidence and points in english already, don't have to worry about translating them.
one more thing, when you point some evidence out, make sure you mention in your debate that it comes from " XXX source" , it's more powerful that way.

Answer 2

如果這是辯論的題目，那麼這個題目不是適用於辯論的題目。這個題目適合作為作文或演講的題目，也適用於討論。請注意：是討論而非辯論！作為辯論的題目要有爭議性才可以！例如，中國統一還是台灣獨立，贊成墮胎還是反對墮胎，進化還是創造，民主好還是專制好，文科有用還是理科有，中醫好還是西醫好......等等。就這樣

Answer 3

Good
thing that i major in this

okay, so there are some evidence that you can present

San Francisco Treaty of Peace with Japan,
1951
Chapter II, Article 2, Item b: Japan
renounces all right, title and claim to Formosa
(Taiwan)
and the Pescadores. (Penghu)

note that the phrase "to China"
was never used here, because neither ROC nor PRC was in the conference.
Therefore, Taiwan is
lawfully not a part of China.

Also, try to mention that there is a significant difference culture-wise, and a
fundamental difference in terms of political systems.