What about the immoral component of what Mexico is doing?

Question

No one has addressed the immoral actions of Mexico's ruling class of actively deporting/exporting those who they feel are the undesirable segment of their population to the U.S.?

I'm singling out Mexico since they've been able to "cleanse" their country of around 10% of it's population, who are now illegally in the U.S.

Answer 1

Mexico has a great responsibility for the illegal alien problem in the USA. Mexico is pushing it's overpopulation of poor and needy citizens off on a neighboring nation, expecting the USA to support them. It is immoral, irresponsible, and the nation of Mexico should be sanctioned by the world court for encouraging and promoting illegal entry to the USA and flagrant violation of the United States borders and laws.

Illegal aliens who make a premeditated decision to violate the laws of the United States, to breach our international borders with foreign nations in violation of United States sovereignty, are criminals and they have nobody to blame for the crimes they commit than themselves.

Anyone who puts the blame for illegal immigration solely on the backs of criminal employers of illegal aliens has rocks in their heads:

No employers bring in all the women who have anchor babies here, a net drain.
No employers bring in all the illegal alien kids who are costing taxpayers billions to educate, while they contribute NOTHING to this country, a net drain.
No employers are bringing in all the millions of unemployed illegal alien criminals who hang out at so-called "day labor pick up spots".
Those people made a premeditated decision to become a criminal by illegally entering the USA, to break our laws.

Answer 2

Like it or not, this so called "ruling class" are the few entrepenuers who were lucky enough to be able to start a successful business in an overwhelming socialist system that is anti-capitalistic and anti free market. If America's corporate populous was reduced to 2-3% the size it is now, we'd call them the "ruling elite" or some other ridiculuous nomenclature. That is the exact problem in Mexico that has lead to economic calamity, not ENOUGH businesses. Since they arent enough companies to employ the people theyve got, many are left selling tangarines on the corner or coming here for more opportunity. They need to reduce their taxes and ridiuclous regualtions to allow free enterprise and allow producutivity like most industrialized nations have done. I think with the right (conservative pro business leaders) they can in time.

Answer 3

The Mexican government benefits from the money illegal aliens send back there which is spent and eventually makes it's way into the government and wealthy pockets.
Mexico can avoid developinig social reform as long they continue to "export" primarily their uneducated citizens.
Mexico is hypocritical considering their tough and enforced immigration laws. Hypocritical in blaming our lax border for the ease their drug cartels find in smuggling drugs, yet demand we do not secure the border.
They want our "milk and honey", yet they do nothing to provide their own.

Perhaps it is time the UN casts a disparaging look at Mexico and demand humanitarian reform there.

Answer 4

I'm sorry if you've misunderstood Mexico's stand on illegal immigration.Some words of the President of Mexico have been so misconstrued over the years it's pathetic.When we implemented NAFTA the President of Mexico praised the U S as a good partner and said it opened opportunities to the Mexican people.He also gave ways of how it opened job opportunities in the States.We didn't have a working relationship with the previous President of Mexico and he was corrupt with drug smuggling.NAFTA ended up hurting the Mexican economy instead of helping it.Now we have millions fleeing Mexico because of NAFTA and the President of Mexico being called a bad guy because he got into a bad trade agreement by his people and here we say he encourages illegal immigration which he doesn't.Please for your own sake on this issue read more on NAFTA and all it entails.For both countries.

Answer 5

The only place you have to look to find the source of the immigration problem is the very top. As long as business owners hire illegal immigrants and landowners rent to illegal immigrants, there will be illegal immigrants. Mexico's ruling class is taking advantage of the short-sighted selfishness and insatiable greed of the ruling class of the United States.

Answer 6

When it come to money there are no morals in some eye>An after being here illegally making money like never before, than they will have to go back to the extreme low wages an life stile.They should of learned English an came here legally>

Answer 7

Nobody wants to talk about that. We are supposed to assume that nothing can be done about their corrupt government. That's what the Mexican illegals keep saying. But if they were no longer permitted to come here things would get interesting in Mexico. I for one would love to see them take a stand and fight for their rights at home. But they never will unless we close the border and give them no choice.

Answer 8

Vicente Fox (ex-president of Mexico) is one of the smartest politicians who has ever lived. He has sold the U.S. on the fact that his ILLEGAL labor is just as marketable a resource as oil and minerals. Realizing he cannot clean up 70 years of the PRI government, he jumped in bed with Bush.

As a result, Mexico does not have to clean its dirty house. They can send their malcontents here to clean toilets and mow lawns, and they send their remittances home! Mexico gets lots of money introduced into its economy without having to reform at all.

The upper classes get to keep what they have, and everyone is happy. Why SHOULD Mexico clean up its act if we continue to accept the status quo? Does anyone ELSE out there see what is happening besides me?

Answer 9

If Mexico can do it, we can too. Send them back and give them Commandant Marco's email address

Answer 10

ok, I can buy that....but it isnt any more immoral than what our politicians and corporate America is doing by hiring illegals, outsourcing jobs and by not enforcing our immigration laws....we arent any better than the mexican government is in reality...so when before we start hacking away at the mexican government and their ruling class, maybe we should start to clean up our own backyard first...