who agree's with me?

Question

I want to know how many people agree that children that are born in America to illegal aliens should not be US citizens.........the only way they can be US citizens is if their parent/s are at the time of their birth....I believe this is a loop hole that needs to be cut!

For those of you who do not agree with me.........I want to know why in a educated response....I am not racist........I am not just talking about Mexican illegal immigrants..............I am talking about every other country other than ours.......My grandmother came from England in the 1940's and became a legal citizen after her green card expired ...........I am far from racist.........stop playing the race card

Again.........I feel it is not right to be able to use your child as a anchor......that is total BS! I understand what our founding fathers wanted......for their country.......however our founding fathers are not here and do not see our economic & governmental problems caused by this loop hole......If these Idiots in our government need to wake the hell up! This would fix some of the BS! And we could just go from there......It is not my fault I am a REAL American......yes my grandmother came from England in 1940.....all the rest of my family had been here since the begining.......so I am a American.........people who cross the border just to have their children to stay here should not be considered the same.............

To all of you that are saying you do not agree.......can you read? I asked to explain why you do not in an educated answer........telling me I do not know Sh** and calling me out of my name is not educated...........why are you answering questions that you obviously cannot comprehend? IGNORANCE IS BLISS ISN"T IT!!!

Answer 1

I agree with you 100%. I don't understand why we keep rewarding these menaces for their criminal behavior. I know the children are innocent. I know that. I just believe that the parents should have to be held accountable for their actions instead of taking for granted that no matter what happens, their offspring here are going to be taken care of by the American tax payers.

Answer 2

Girl you have no idea what you're talking about in 1940 nobody wanted to come to the US. The US Became something after WWII and then was when immigration laws became more strict. Before that anyone could come to the US because the requirements were not hard to meet.

Regarding the children thing. When the first immigrants came here there were no immigration laws, so every kid born here was considered american, if it would had not been like that, there would had not been any revolution, because if the ones born here were not americans but Englands, then they would be fighting againts their own goverment, but the ones born here were different people from englands and thats why they could fight againts them. They would had not fought them if they would had felt part of them.

Children are innocent and they are not guilty for their parents mistakes. They dont choose where they are born. So any kid born here deserves to be called american. Thats what the constitution says, and you cant change what the founders of this country wanted since the beginning.

Answer 3

I agree that if BOTH parents are illegal, they all get deported>> No matter WHERE the child was born. However, I believe that if AT LEAST ONE of that childs parents is a legal American citizen that child should be considered an AMERICAN citizen. I have read accounts where a woman who is an American citizen marries a man from an Eastern country (Pakistan, Afganistan..) has a child here, they divorce and HE takes the child back to that country. The mother never sees the child again, even though the child was BORN here of a legal citizen. USA citizens who have children BORN here should keep their children HERE.

Answer 4

I do not agree with you.

Children Born to illegal Aliens are allowed to be documented because they were born in the U.S. and not elsewhere. As such, they are entitled to the Rights and Privileges of the land in which they were born. If an American is in another country, legally or illegaly, and has a child on foreign soil then their children are usually considered citizens of the country in which the child was born. Of course, that's depending on where you are. As such, America has the same rules about immigrant births as many other countries.

You are racist. You may not think it, but some part of you is racist enough to ask that question.

Answer 5

What you are saying makes way too much sense for it to ever pass. The politicians are scared to propose any such thing because the Hispanic vote reflects the largest minority. Apparently it doesnt make a difference that 95% of Americans are totally fed up with the problem.
I agree with you 100%. Now, the Republicans have done NOTHING. God forbid a Democrat gets in office, it will only get worse. We're screwed.

Answer 6

Every race came to america at one point or another whether it was thousands of years ago or 100 years ago. I actually think that they should make it easier for mexicans to become citizens. you don't understand it is not because they want to immigrate illegally it is because they have to come to this great country we call america just because you were lucky enough to be born here. Mexico is one if not the worst place to live even the presidents are currupt or druglords, plus you have to pay for school, you got low paying jobs, and no law inforsement cops are litttle bitches .sry. See i have a different perspective i was american by choice so i don't take this country for granted. I am glad i took my chances here illegaly but no i am legal so im not worried so instead of not letting people live a better life enjoy yours because as you read this approximately 30 people have died in mexico, and about 40 in cuba.

Answer 7

My understanding is that the Supreme Court never actually ruled on this point, but specifically reserved it. So I reserve my opinion on what the Constitution says on this point, as well.

I agree it is bad policy, but I don't like messing with the Constitution unless necessary.

However, I am all for doing away with 'family reunification' preferences for anyone who did not have a legal permenant resident parent or citizen parent at the time of their birth. That would keep illegals from being able to 'leverage themself' in by giving birth in the US.

Answer 8

I agree! They come here to have "anchor babies". That's what they look at them as, an anchor within the law that allows them to stay here. And do you know that "anchor baby's" give them the right to draw welfare just because the baby was born here. When my son was born my wife and I had to show valid identification when his birth certificate was filled out and we are born here! So how do they get a birth certificate if they don't have a valid ID? And that is a huge anchor by the way. They need to weigh anchor and go back home if they don't want to do it right!

Answer 9

To bad america is built on Loop holes, here is one you probably didn't know, the King of Thailand was born in Boston, The most loved King and probably the best King in the world today, and he is actually an American because he was born in America, go figure!

Answer 10

I agree 100%