Why the Protestants think that Catholics are not Christians--only they are and vice-versa?

Answer 1

Catholics believe that Protestants are Christians.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church states:

"Many elements of sanctification and of truth" are found outside the visible confines of the Catholic Church: "the written Word of God; the life of grace; faith, hope, and charity, with the other interior gifts of the Holy Spirit, as well as visible elements."

Christ's Spirit uses these Churches and ecclesial communities as means of salvation.

All these blessings come from Christ and lead to him.

With love in Christ.

Answer 2

Shawn, final question first. No, the 1st Christians have been born and raised Jewish yet depended on Jesus Christ as Messiah, Savior, and Lord. The Gospels and the e book of Acts share that tale. The term "catholic", meaning international or universal, did no longer seem used plenty for some years. So no, the 1st Christians weren't catholics. As for the badmouthing, specific, there has been an mind-blowing form of that from the two factors. element of that's per incorrect information and a few on miscommunication, however the actuality is that there are some substantial adjustments in concept between the denominations. regrettably, there is no longer one church or denomination that thoroughly follows the classes of the hot testomony. some come close, to be honest, and a few are, nicely, no longer even close. till now you're making a call, please take a deeper inspect what the denominations truly have self assurance. i comprehend for a actuality that there are some denominations that flat-out say "till you connect us, you haven't any longer have been given a desire of Heaven", etc., etc. some denominations have a catechism, or application of coaching, that would desire to steer you into their particular concept gadget. a number of Christian bookstores (even possibly Barnes & Noble, etc) have bought those interior the previous; some nonetheless do. study and heed, then see how they examine to the Bible. i desire you're analyzing your Bible many times. (friends, this placed up isn't, repeat no longer, meant as a bash or rant against any church or denomination. Please do no longer interpret this as a rant or bash or the rest.) finally, the suitable Christian faith, for you, is the only that preaches the Bible many times and explains it to you so as which you will comprehend it. (i've got listened to 3 sermons that I had no concept what the preacher became speaking approximately!!) pattern a number of and pray--God will lead you to the suitable suited place. and don't hesitate to ask questions, as there are lots of people who would be happy to respond to any questions you ought to have.

Answer 3

Part of the problem is that scriptural Christianity and the lives of people here in America tend to differ. At the root of it, Christianity holds that Christ is superior to man; not equal to man (man is a false god; Gen. 3). All men make mistakes; (for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God. Romans 3:23).
There is a man-made old testament of Genesis-Malachi, and the scriptural old testament; i.e. the law of Moses. (Per scripture, the old testament was done away; Hebrews). The Jews were told to have two or more witnesses (about three times Deut. 10-20), and the Christians were given the same command (Matt. 18:16, 2 Cor. 13:1). When this concept is applied, one finds the 'old testament' is the law of Moses. My 'two or more witnesses' for that assertion include Joshua (Joshua 8:31), David (2 Kings 2:3), Solomon (1 Kings 8:9), Nehemiah (Nehemiah 8:1), Daniel (Daniel 9:11-13), Malachi (Malachi 4:4)i, Jesus (Matt. 19:7-9), God the Father (Matt. 17; in effect he backs up whatever Jesus his Son says), and the apostle Paul. (The law is referred to as the old testament (KJV), many other English versions translate it as old covenant in 2 Cor. 3:13-14). Perhaps this is part of why the beast in Revelation 17 is the USA, and the harlot Babylon is the leadership of the USA. (See what happens to the beast and harlot in Revelation 18).
God apparently had me think of this text recently; Acts 18:24-28 (please read) regarding Priscilla, Aquilla, and Apollos. Apparently, Apollos was eager to grow. I hope many Christians in this country presently are in the Apollos category.
A major difference between Catholics and Protestants stems fro the fact that they utilize different Bibles. Speaking personally, I was raised in a “Protestant’ congregation". However, after studying for myself as an adult, I now agree on this component with the Catholic faith. (I disagree with the Catholic faith on other aspects).

Answer 4

I am a protestant and I believe that if you accept Jesus Christ as your personal Savior then you are a Christian, I don't care what religion you are. But most of the other protestants I know disagree with me because Catholics and others don't practice the same way we do.

Answer 5

Many Protestants consider the Catholic idea of Tradition (with a capital T) to be in opposition to Scripture. There are lots of other borderline-bigoted reasons too.

It is the official position of the Church that Protestants are, indeed, Christians, the current term used to describe them is "Seperated Brethren."

Answer 6

Catholics are Christians.
A Christian is anyone who has believes that Jesus was born of a virgin birth, lived a life without sin, took on the sins of mankind and died in our place to attone for our sins. Any person who asks Jesus for forgiveness of their sins and turns their life over to Him to follow His will is a Christian
There are doctrinal differences between Catholics and Prostestants but there are also doctrinal differences between Protestants themselves. How we worship God and talk to God isn't what is important.
Jesus said that no man may come to the Father except thru Him. And the bible says that God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son, that whosoever believes in Him shall have everlasting life.
This is the common ground of all Christians.

Answer 7

I am protestant, and I think that Catholics are Christians. Catholics beliefs are not all the same as Protestants, but all Christians view Jesus Christ as their saviour, whether they are Catholic or Protestant. Hence, they are CHRISTians. From there, their beliefs separate into separate denominations, based on their belief or disbelief in things like purgatory, saints, the need for confession, the importance of baptism, etc., basically, into the rules that turn faith into rigid religion. But it is their relationship with Christ, rather than their denomination, that makes them Christian. At least, that is my belief. Thanks for the 2 points.

Answer 8

I read some of the others answers and I'm amazed that none of you consider what a true christian is but would rather concentrate on what religion is and how it relates to christian beliefs in your religion. I'm not Catholic nor Protestant,nor Pagan, nor Jew but I'm still a Christian.If you know what it truly means to be Christian then you understand where I'm coming from.

Answer 9

Protestants think Catholics are idolaters and try to add too much to the bible that wasn't orignally there... both in tradition and in their hierarchy.

Catholics feel that they have the God-given, biblical right to make the changes that they have made, and that Protestants are, at heart, just in rebellion against the rightful and original church that Jesus started.

Sane people think they're both kidding themselves and are holding on to a dying and baffling mythology for dear life.

Answer 10

Because their Christ is apparently different from the one they believe in. I get this all the time about my religion. I'm christian, but am told that I'm not, because my Christ is a different one they believe. My Christ is the same one that they believe in, the one from the Bible, the same one who suffered in Gathsemene, the same one that died on the cross, the same one that rose three days later. Just because we have a different book that is another testiment of Christ, they think we aren't christians.

We all just need to get over it and be tolerant of others and what they believe. I don't care if you don't believe what I believe, just don't bash my beliefs just to try and make yourself look, or feel better. That will come to no good end and as it is said, contention is of the devil.